So my little group (55 shaman, 56 warlock, 56 mage, 57 priest (shadow), and me, 57 paladin) decided to give Ramparts a shot, just to see what happened. From the looks of things, it's doable (up to the first boss, at least), but I was having trouble dealing with the punt/aggro loss on the Destroyers; with my group being underleveled for the instance, it makes getting them back on me (and not beating on the shaman) a top priority.
My first strategy (after I found out that they punted) was to just hit taunt as soon as I took off. This worked the first time, but the second time taunt failed to go off, for some reason, and the shaman was so much red paste. Is it better to HoJ on a punt, and then take back control?
_________________
