Which shield?

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Sunstrider&n=Gingfreeks

Should I go for the badge shield or not. I lose a bit of def but I'm still over uncrit and I gain some dodge. Or should I hold on to the def.

If you can maintain the minimum defense, I would get the dodge trinket instead.
_________________
I reserve the right to refuse service to those that do not read the stickies.