Warriors
can tank P3.
Paladins
can tank P2 (I've done it - no warrior available).
However both decisions are equally retarded. Tell you raid leader than MC called, and it wants it's 1.0 tactics back.
If you do get P3 tanking: Stick yourself in a caster group with Shadow Priest & Shaman, wear a max threat set (keep some avoidance / uncrushable), pop Wings + Icon of the Silver Cresent + Destruction Pot early and go to town. We're killing Brute, my DPS isn't capped for P3.
Warriors do substantially less threat and take a TON more damage. I've seen a mostly T-6 geared warrior gibbed by "Dance to Battle -> big-auto from RoS -> Full Rage -> Scream -> Splutch".
That was the last time a warrior tanked RoS P3 for my guild.
_________________
