Skip to content
Maintankadin

Enchanting Your Gloves: 2% vs 20 +dmg vs Mitigation

Levantine
The extra health is static, while the armour continues to work.

~120 health is ~120 health, whereas the mitigation from the armour will mitigate much much more damage over the course of a boss fight.

No one is saying that stamina is bad, but if you really need that extra ~120 health to survive the burst of the encounter, then something is probably up.
_________________
Retired untill Whatlick
bubblecannon
No, no no no... 120 health is not static.

That 120 health is working HARDER for you than your armor. It's providing a constant meat buffer for both melee and spell damage absorption before you die!

IMHO this is what is wrong with some of the tanking theory.

I'm happy to admit I'm wrong, but someone explain to me how that HP doesn't increase your EH just like armor does. And flat out 120 HP -is- a far larger EH increase than 240 armor at anything above like 1K armor.
(and for 25% of the ILEVEL)

The only thing armor does for you is decrease your incoming DPS. If healers have spare capacity to match that increased incoming DPS than armor provides you virtually nothing compared to stam.

Edit: fixed typos.
_________________
[img][/img]
Levantine
Mmm, I'm too tired to nut out the math for it (a big eff you, uni), but I'm sure one of the harder theory crafters will come up with something.

Either that or you'll keep on the stam is king train. *shrug*
_________________
Retired untill Whatlick
bubblecannon
I'd far prefer to be corrected and gearing my pally correctly, however I'm finding it really hard to agree with the math being presented.

I don't disagree that armor can beat stam with sufficient amounts of it but simply that people are over-rating it significantly.

I'd love to reach an agreement as to what 240 armor is actually worth in EH compared to a value in stam.
_________________
[img][/img]
Levantine
Completely understandable. I understand the math behind it, but am not putting it forward in any kind of conclusive way due to being overtired. Maybe I'll come back tomorrow or Sunday with a fresh head and see if I can articulate the numbers better, and maybe show some math proof if no one else has. =]
_________________
Retired untill Whatlick
Marker
There is no single correct answer, Armor benefits to effective health are relative and scale with the length of the battle. While Stamina offers a once-off increased HP pool armor reduce the incoming damage by a % for every physical attack taken. Given that your HP pool is big enough to handle the damage-spikes the encounter has to offer, the point where armor surpass stam is where the fight is long enough for you to have mitigated enough incoming dmg to match the static HP buff from stamina.

http://www.theoryspot.com/forums/tankspot-library/1060-effective-health-theory.html
bubblecannon
Hmm.

Stam and armor are generally added only to increase effective health.
Mitigation of incoming DPS to decrease healer load is generally unnecessary.

So whilst it is true to say that armor provides a net DPS decrease over the entire fight, it doesn't mean that the statement has any real value. (When we're talking about +-10%). Perhaps my lack of experience is showing but in every fight, up to and including Kael/Vashj overheal has always been quite high (ie. their is a lot of excess healing capacity).

The real argument is where you say 'HP pool is big enough to handle the damage-spikes the encounter has to offer'. This is the crux of it. For the fight do you have enough EH? Now if you already do, then you should be adding more threat. If you don't, then stam seems to be your friend.
_________________
[img][/img]
Minn
It depends on how you look at marginal stamina. Is that +10 sta kit providing your first 126 hitpoints, in which case you're getting an extra 126 hp from it every time a heal takes you back to full? Is it your last 126 hps, in which case you may not ever need it at all? Somewhere in between? Either way, stamina doesn't provide any mitigation of incoming damage, it just makes that damage less likely to kill you.

I think looking at it from a "which one makes me harder to kill from full health" perspective makes the most sense. In my case, armor wins. I'm not sure where the breaking point is, but 10 sta may win out for some tanks.
_________________
Last seen wearing...
Alacia
According to my spreadsheet (using the calculations found here) the 10 stamina and 240 armor enchants will be equal at around 15,5k hp and 20k armor (randomly chosen values, this isn't linear). At higher hp/lower armor the 240 armor patch will win out for EH. And well (assuming the calculations are correct! Razz), I honestly can't see any non-bears running around with stats that would make the 10 stamina superior to 240 armor for physical EH.
_________________
Neganur
the gloves and cloak armor enchants seem not affected by the toughness talent btw.
_________________