Skip to content
Maintankadin

Crusade Spec Worthless in Ulduar?

Oryann

Crusade Spec Worthless in Ulduar?

Is it just me or aren't the bosses in Ulduar giants? Wouldn't that make the crusade spec worthless?
Mavrix
Crusade does a flat 3% damage increase regardless of mob type then an additional 3% on the specified mob types. 3% damage against giants is still worthwhile.
Dorvan
Mavrix wrote:Crusade does a flat 3% damage increase regardless of mob type then an additional 3% on the specified mob types. 3% damage against giants is still worthwhile.


^^ This.
Torquemada
Yeah. 6% damage plus 3% crit(Taking Conviction to get to Crusade) against most mob types and a mere 3% damage and 3% crit against giants and mechanicals is worth the points to me.

Oh, and I would still probably spec for Crusade like this, but that's me.
Oryann
Ya I understand the 3% more damage part but I have not had any problems with threat ever...(minus the one time I left my healing shield and mace on for maly by accident) As it stands right now I was planning on maintanking Hodir in Ulduar with a Death Knight in full Frost resist as an OT. I was thinking another Mitigation CD such as imp lay on hand could be worthwhile. Oh and WTF where is our glyph of divine protection to give it a 1 minute CD

Also here is a link of a Saph fight that I MT..Its pretty cool because you can see the air phases and the 969 rotation very clearly. The air phases also lowers my overall TPS quite significantly....Besides the one rotation error I had.
http://www.wowmeteronline.com/combat/de ... #realtime5
Dorvan
Well, your phrasing of "worthless" evoked the responses you got. Obviously it's not worthless. Certainly an Imp LoH spec is the main alternative to a 0/53/18 spec, but I see Imp LoH as fairly expensive at 7 talent points. If threat turns out to be a non-issue and Imp LoH looks like it'll be very helpful, I could see going that route, but a priori 0/53/18 seems like it gets you more bang for your buck.
Regan
3% more threat (some more with the points in conviction) = 2 more seconds the new HoS glyph can tick.


(probably faulty math, but you get the idea, threat is good now)
Anacharial
Specced 0/53/18 for as long as I could.

Awesome threat and damage. :D

Very good for PuG raids as you get a e-peen the damage meters :D
Akairos
I'm already specced for crusade.
When 3.0 comes and you all spec it, I will reference this post to let everyone know I was cool before it became commonplace.
KysenMurrin
You gave up 6% spell damage mitigation for it, and part of Ardent Defender. There's a bit of a difference between speccing for it now (give up tanking talents) and in 3.1 (have the points to spare).

You also took Benediction instead of Conviction, which is weird in a threat build.
Akairos
KysenMurrin wrote:You gave up 6% spell damage mitigation for it, and part of Ardent Defender. There's a bit of a difference between speccing for it now (give up tanking talents) and in 3.1 (have the points to spare).

You also took Benediction instead of Conviction, which is weird in a threat build.

I'm leaving sartharion+anything out of any argument I might try to rebut with, as most other content is trivial as it stands and 1 gimmicky fight is not a good bench marker for the effectiveness of a talent build or gear set up.
I do however concede to the power of spell mitigation and AD when doing sarth+3 attempts as an add tank, I will say that.
5/5 AD hardly make/breaks something as the only time you are below 35%, usually the boss will kill you anyhow, 1 point out of it is no biggie.
I could put the point's in conviction, 2% crit is really not much of a help either when my own crit is abysmal, I can try it out I guess. :<
In current content there are few needs for the mitigation
. malygos does big magic damage, I specced GBtL for progression kills, he is now on farm.
. Sarth
. Kel'thuzad single target frostbolt is debatable, but it should be interrupted every time.
. Gothik can kill you if you somehow get like 7+ debuff stacks on you
. Grand Widow's rain of fire?
theckhd
/brokenrecord

0/5x/18 with 3/3 Crusade is the highest-threat build we can get without dropping to 0/51/20 and giving up core tanking talents.

I expect to see a lot of 0/5x/18 specced paladins once 3.1 comes out.
Dorvan
Akairos wrote:I'm already specced for crusade.
When 3.0 comes and you all spec it, I will reference this post to let everyone know I was cool before it became commonplace.


The fact that it's a good spec once changes are made to the talent trees doesn't make it a good spec now, anymore than Paladin tanks who insisted on using King's Defender all the time were "ahead of the curve" because Tankadins now use melee tank weapons.