Cloack enchant, Dodge or agility

[Alexander]

Whats more usefull for a cloack. Half of my guildies are saying the dodge version, the other half are saying the Agility (since that helpes dodge too)
(needless to say i'm a tankadin)

Your views?

[Lorath]

For tankadin? Dodge, no contest.
GL finding it tho Rarest enchant ever on my server

[Everlight]

The Dodge enchant is slightly better for pure avoidance than the Agility enchant.

But the Agility one is way easier to get done.

[Livyan]

Repeating previous posters: Dodge > Agility
But it's hard to find an enchanter, and the mats are horrible to farm (Damn Guardian Stones never drop!).
Other than that, seeing that "every little bit helps", I might go with Armor sometime in the future.. =)

[Joanadark]

The Duck goesssss "Cloack"

[Gideon]

I have access to the dodge enchant (one of my co-tanks has the recipe on his alt and yes he is bitter about this). However I currently have 120 AC on my devilshark.

Given that I am uncrushable already, which do I go for?

[Daromire]

more avoidance never hurts man.

[Novariety]

I have access to the dodge enchant (one of my co-tanks has the recipe on his alt and yes he is bitter about this). However I currently have 120 AC on my devilshark.

Given that I am uncrushable already, which do I go for?

I feel his pain, only one to have the dodge enchant horde side on my server and it is on an alt .

[Livyan]

more avoidance never hurts man.

Quoted for Truth.

[Semirhage]

I have access to the dodge enchant (one of my co-tanks has the recipe on his alt and yes he is bitter about this). However I currently have 120 AC on my devilshark.

Given that I am uncrushable already, which do I go for?

For $25 bucks plus a new account, he can xfer a character.

[Arcand]

The +120 armor one ends up giving you an extra 132 armor, which is something like a 1% increase to your effective health. (More like 0.86% now, but anyway.) Mats aren't too bad, either.

Just throwing that out there.

[Gideon]

Entered the three possibilities into tankpoints. I couldn't be bothered to factor the Toughness talent but accepted that there would be some margin for error.

Tankpoints showed a better total damage reduction (and number of tankpoints, though that is usually not important to me) with the agility enchant.

The order TP gave was: 12 agility > 120 AC > 12 dodge rating.

I imagine that dodge > all if you're still crushable though.

[Arcand]

How big a difference was there between the three? I'm wondering, for example, if it's significant that BoK boosts the agility enchant but not the other two.

[Eloff]

BoK makes the difference in dodge/anti-crush equal to .1%

But the dodge enchant still comes out on top for anti-crush. However, agility does give some value in armor (anyone have a conversion rate formula for that?) so maybe that's why they thought it was better???

[Drfeelgood]

BoK makes the difference in dodge/anti-crush equal to .1%

But the dodge enchant still comes out on top for anti-crush. However, agility does give some value in armor (anyone have a conversion rate formula for that?) so maybe that's why they thought it was better???

I believe agility converts to AC at a rate of 1 agi: 2ac.