I've only been able to find lvl 85 dummies in orgrimmar
but i just tested Judgement on a lvl 93 and a lvl 85 dummy and the difference is -/+ 1, as you said, so should I stick to lvl 93 dummies instead?
A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Yeah, given that information, 93 dummies can be used for everything. In fact, you could use any level dummy for the spell damage ones, it's only the weapon/physical damage ones (melee, CS, HotR) that absolutely have to be level 93 (because armor values change with dummy level).
I'm trying to get what I can out of the data sets you provided as we speak, using tweaked spellpower values (modifying the third one to be exactly half of the AP value). I think I've convinced myself that your Judgement data is consistent with the tooltip values (though again, a low- or zero-sp data point would help that a lot).
<edit> after some more testing, I think that the AP values from sets 2-4 are correct, but the SP values from 2 & 3 are off (as indicated by the ratios). In addition, both values from set 1 are wrong (both too high). If I fit vs. AP, values from sets 2-5 all fit very, very well with the tooltip formula for Judgment. But the first data point is always very low, and drags the intercept down. So far, I'm concluding that I can use sets 2-5 under the assumption that the AP data is correct, but I'll have to toss set 1 unless further data suggests it's correct.
I'm trying to get what I can out of the data sets you provided as we speak, using tweaked spellpower values (modifying the third one to be exactly half of the AP value). I think I've convinced myself that your Judgement data is consistent with the tooltip values (though again, a low- or zero-sp data point would help that a lot).
<edit> after some more testing, I think that the AP values from sets 2-4 are correct, but the SP values from 2 & 3 are off (as indicated by the ratios). In addition, both values from set 1 are wrong (both too high). If I fit vs. AP, values from sets 2-5 all fit very, very well with the tooltip formula for Judgment. But the first data point is always very low, and drags the intercept down. So far, I'm concluding that I can use sets 2-5 under the assumption that the AP data is correct, but I'll have to toss set 1 unless further data suggests it's correct.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
don't worry, I'm doing new sets -- just to verify things
Here is the first one.
Naked
Str 176
Agi 107
Sta 332
Int 117
AP 602
SP 301
Haste 0
Hit 0
Crit 5.01
Exp 0
The problem I had with the first set 1 was that I used an epic shield -- that's why it's out of whack
Here is the first one.
Naked
Str 176
Agi 107
Sta 332
Int 117
AP 602
SP 301
Haste 0
Hit 0
Crit 5.01
Exp 0
The problem I had with the first set 1 was that I used an epic shield -- that's why it's out of whack
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
- Code: Select all
set #1 set #2 set #3 set #4
Str 1624 2953 4481 5931
Agi 107
Sta 3244 5675 8587 11365
Int 117
AP 3498 6156 9212 12112
SP 1749 3078 4606 6056
Haste 0 0.76 3.07 3.07
Hit 0 0.62 0.62 1.97
Crit 5.36 5.36 6.30 7.31
Exp 2.55 3.89 3.89 3.89
I'll have more sets after the server reset.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
- Code: Select all
set #5 set #6 set #7
Str 7580 8690 10566
Sta 15355 17365
AP 15410 17630 21382
SP 7705 8815 10691
Haste 4.40 4.40
Hit 1.97 3.37
Crit 8.53 8.53
Exp 3.89 3.89
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Set 6 and 7 data
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Data set for #29, using a rogue:
AGI: 3650
AP: 9562
crit: 25.92%
haste: 21.47% (plus procs from arrow of time and the hungerer)
~1.5 hours on a level 70 target dummy:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/ii5v ... details/0/
~2.5 hours on a level 85 target dummy:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/ijv9 ... etails/21/
AGI: 3650
AP: 9562
crit: 25.92%
haste: 21.47% (plus procs from arrow of time and the hungerer)
~1.5 hours on a level 70 target dummy:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/ii5v ... details/0/
~2.5 hours on a level 85 target dummy:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/ijv9 ... etails/21/
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Thanks Klaud, I've entered all of the data in and am starting to fit it. So far the static abilities are fitting beautifully. I haven't started on the ones that depend on weapon damage yet, probably tomorrow or this evening.
Weapon was still a club, right?
Weapon was still a club, right?
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
yes, club.
Let me know if you need granularity for the tests, the way I did it is that each set increments the pieces of gear by 2. So I start naked, then I add helm and neck, then next set is shoulders and cloak and so on -- let me know if you need odd number of pieces equipped just to verify and I'll get on that.
Let me know if you need granularity for the tests, the way I did it is that each set increments the pieces of gear by 2. So I start naked, then I add helm and neck, then next set is shoulders and cloak and so on -- let me know if you need odd number of pieces equipped just to verify and I'll get on that.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Are you sure you used a club for the first round of testing? Because something isn't adding up. For example, this time around, in set #7 with 21k AP, your CS is hitting for 4777-4780. In set #5 from a few weeks ago, with 19.8k AP, you were hitting for 10713-15790. Not only are the values much larger, but the range is much larger. I haven't had time yet to figure out what I expect from the formulas, but just looking at the data, something looks fishy.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
A problem I had with the sets I submitted a while back is that I didn't use a white shield, I used an epic shield... The original request had them asking for club as your weapon, they didn't mention a white quality shield -- but I did use one for today's sets
It's possible I fucked up something on the previous sets -- or rather, it's almost certain -- considering I just logged in back to beta and verified that CS is giving me ~4778 damage
I'm thinking I probably equipped the epic pvp mace by accident
EDIT: Just went back and equipped the mace and the shield, and removed my str trinkets... I hit CS and almost matches the results of #5 from last week... I fail orz
It's possible I fucked up something on the previous sets -- or rather, it's almost certain -- considering I just logged in back to beta and verified that CS is giving me ~4778 damage
I'm thinking I probably equipped the epic pvp mace by accident
EDIT: Just went back and equipped the mace and the shield, and removed my str trinkets... I hit CS and almost matches the results of #5 from last week... I fail orz
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Theck : Sure enough, we've got blocked criticals. Much to my own amusement, even blocked glancing blows (which weren't there in early beta, IIRC). At this point it seems they went with the easy route, simply injecting another roll for any event that happens to deal damage in the first place.
Yet another glorious example of misinformation. Gotta love the man. Hell, I wonder how many people still believe that parryhaste is gone "because GC said so".
Yet another glorious example of misinformation. Gotta love the man. Hell, I wonder how many people still believe that parryhaste is gone "because GC said so".
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Klaudandus wrote:It's possible I fucked up something on the previous sets -- or rather, it's almost certain -- considering I just logged in back to beta and verified that CS is giving me ~4778 damage
I'm thinking I probably equipped the epic pvp mace by accident
EDIT: Just went back and equipped the mace and the shield, and removed my str trinkets... I hit CS and almost matches the results of #5 from last week... I fail orz
That's fine, as long as the AP/SP values are correct. I'll just exclude the old results from my fits for weapon-damage-based abilities. The new ones should span the space well enough to give me good results.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
good, just let me know if you need anything else, and g'luck with the moving.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Just checking in - I'm not dead, the move went well, and I'm hoping to get some time to finish up the spell coefficient calculations in the next day or two. I'm over halfway done, but haven't gotten to look at them since last Thursday. So far, all of the ones I've finished match the wowdb tooltips exactly, which was more or less expected.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
X-posted because it might be relevant
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/forum/topic ... 430?page=1
Some reports have prot pallies doing about 60% of a Blood DK, and (apparently due to a bug) 22% of what brewmasters do it.
Q:SOTR hits for about 1/4th of what it hits for on live. CS/HOTR also hit for much, much less.
A:If you post approximate damage numbers for those attacks along with your character level and average ilevel (just the average is fine), we can compare them to our numbers.
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/forum/topic ... 430?page=1
Some reports have prot pallies doing about 60% of a Blood DK, and (apparently due to a bug) 22% of what brewmasters do it.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Your SotR data exactly matched the tooltip, 617+0.54*AP.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
theckhd wrote:Your SotR data exactly matched the tooltip, 617+0.54*AP.
Any idea why CS is hitting like a wet noodle?
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Not yet, I'm looking at that now. That was the ability I was working on when I had to pack up, and I didn't get a chance to work out the new armor reduction factor before I did that. I was hoping that would fix the discrepancy between data and tooltip.
<edit> but I can't seem to find level 93 armor values. I know I've seen them somewhere recently, but damned if I can find them now that I need them...
<edit> but I can't seem to find level 93 armor values. I know I've seen them somewhere recently, but damned if I can find them now that I need them...
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Ok, can't find the armor data, but I can extrapolate based on the melee data. From the max melee swings, I can infer that the physical damage reduction factor [K/(A+K), where K is the armor coefficient tlitp found earlier (25050) and A is the target armor] is around 0.6545. Fitting the CS data with
y=0.6545*(a*x+1123)
gives me:
which isn't too bad given that my 0.6545 is just a rough estimate. We expect the coefficient to be 1.6 based on the tooltip.
y=0.6545*(a*x+1123)
gives me:
- Code: Select all
General model:
f(x) = 0.6545*(a*x+1123)
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 1.676 (1.648, 1.704)
Goodness of fit:
SSE: 1.591e+004
R-square: 0.9988
Adjusted R-square: 0.9988
RMSE: 47.67
which isn't too bad given that my 0.6545 is just a rough estimate. We expect the coefficient to be 1.6 based on the tooltip.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
tangentially related
Yeah, we will try to add dodge from Agi to the Agi and dodge tooltips. Currently they’re just included in the title of each of those tooltips, which are final values after summing all of the sources and applying DR. The “(before diminishing returns)” line in the dodge tooltip, refers just to the “dodge of X adds Y% dodge” line, not the total. It’s somewhat confusing right now. All of this goes for Strength / parry as well.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
All right, I've validated almost all of the spell details now. Luckily, they all pretty much match the tooltip values (if ones are given). Here's the breakdown for each spell. I'm skipping melee/CS/HotR for the moment, as those three depend on the exact armor mitigation factor. Data and fit information is here: https://sites.google.com/site/matlabadi ... fit_data.m
HammerNova:
Tooltip: (840-1261) + 0.234*AP = (840-1261) + 0.468*AP
Fits (min and max):
Result: data seems entirely consistent with tooltip values. Tooltip confirmed.
Seal of Truth:
Tooltip: 14% weapon damage
Fit:
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Censure:
Tooltip: (158+0.138*SP)*5 = 790 + 0.69*SP
Fit:
Result: Tooltip confirmed
Judgment:
Tooltip: 702 + 0.397*AP + 0.635*SP = 702 + 1.429*SP
Fit:
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Holy Wrath:
Tooltip: 4300+0.91*SP
Fit:
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Consecration:
Tooltip: No scaling info provided
Fit:
Result: Cons is 69+0.12*SP damage per tick, total of 690+1.2*SP per cast.
Avenger's Shield:
Tooltip: (4039-4937)+0.21*SP+0.545*AP = (4039-4937)+1.30*SP
Fits (min and max):
Result: Data seems entirely consistent with tooltip (to 95% CI). Tooltip confirmed.
Shield of the Righteous
Tooltip: 617 + 0.54* AP = 617 + 1.08*SP
Fit:
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
HammerNova:
Tooltip: (840-1261) + 0.234*AP = (840-1261) + 0.468*AP
Fits (min and max):
- Code: Select all
hanova_fit =
General model:
hanova_fit(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.4685 (0.4676, 0.4694)
b = 1254 (1248, 1260)
hanova_gof =
sse: 181.8413
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 4.2643
hanova_fit2 =
General model:
hanova_fit2(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.468 (0.4665, 0.4696)
b = 847.9 (837.1, 858.7)
hanova_gof2 =
sse: 576.4841
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 7.5927
Result: data seems entirely consistent with tooltip values. Tooltip confirmed.
Seal of Truth:
Tooltip: 14% weapon damage
Fit:
- Code: Select all
sot_fit =
General model:
sot_fit(x) = a*x
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.14 (0.14, 0.1401)
sot_gof =
sse: 0.0533
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 7
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.0872
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Censure:
Tooltip: (158+0.138*SP)*5 = 790 + 0.69*SP
Fit:
- Code: Select all
cens_fit =
General model:
cens_fit(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.6901 (0.69, 0.6901)
b = 790.2 (789.6, 790.8)
cens_gof =
sse: 1.6780
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.4096
Result: Tooltip confirmed
Judgment:
Tooltip: 702 + 0.397*AP + 0.635*SP = 702 + 1.429*SP
Fit:
- Code: Select all
j_fit =
General model:
j_fit(x) = 702+a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 1.429 (1.429, 1.429)
b = -0.2869 (-1.154, 0.5804)
j_gof =
sse: 3.7250
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.6103
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Holy Wrath:
Tooltip: 4300+0.91*SP
Fit:
- Code: Select all
hw_fit =
General model:
hw_fit(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.91 (0.91, 0.9101)
b = 4301 (4300, 4301)
hw_gof =
sse: 1.3406
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.3661
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Consecration:
Tooltip: No scaling info provided
Fit:
- Code: Select all
cons_fit =
General model:
cos_fit(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.12 (0.12, 0.12)
b = 68.98 (68.89, 69.07)
cons_gof =
sse: 0.0400
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.0632
Result: Cons is 69+0.12*SP damage per tick, total of 690+1.2*SP per cast.
Avenger's Shield:
Tooltip: (4039-4937)+0.21*SP+0.545*AP = (4039-4937)+1.30*SP
Fits (min and max):
- Code: Select all
as_fit =
General model:
as_fit(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 1.299 (1.296, 1.303)
b = 4059 (4033, 4085)
as_gof =
sse: 3.2986e+003
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 18.1621
as_fit2 =
General model:
as_fit2(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 1.302 (1.297, 1.307)
b = 4895 (4861, 4930)
as_gof2 =
sse: 5.9482e+003
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 24.3889
Result: Data seems entirely consistent with tooltip (to 95% CI). Tooltip confirmed.
Shield of the Righteous
Tooltip: 617 + 0.54* AP = 617 + 1.08*SP
Fit:
- Code: Select all
sotr_fit =
General model:
sotr_fit(x) = a*x+b
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 1.08 (1.08, 1.08)
b = 616.8 (616.1, 617.5)
sotr_gof =
sse: 2.6125
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 10
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.5111
Result: Tooltip confirmed.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
By the way, here's what I have for melee, CS, and HotR (phys). I'm using the melee max data to determine the armor coefficient, and using that to fit CS and HotR:
CS is a bit high at 1.7x weapon damage instead of 1.6x. Note that CS is based off of normalized weapon damage, while HotR is not. Once I have level 93 armor values, I'll use the exact values and see if I can do better.
- Code: Select all
melee_fit =
General model:
melee_fit(x) = a*x
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.6545 (0.6453, 0.6637)
melee_gof =
sse: 2.5220e+003
rsquare: 0.9991
dfe: 7
adjrsquare: 0.9991
rmse: 18.9814
cs_fit =
General model:
cs_fit(x) = 0.6545*(a*x+b)
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 1.707 (1.661, 1.753)
b = 1043 (942.4, 1143)
cs_gof =
sse: 9.7370e+003
rsquare: 0.9993
dfe: 6
adjrsquare: 0.9991
rmse: 40.2844
hotr_fit =
General model:
hotr_fit(x) = 0.6545*a*x
Coefficients (with 95% confidence bounds):
a = 0.1992 (0.1989, 0.1995)
hotr_gof =
sse: 0.8558
rsquare: 1.0000
dfe: 7
adjrsquare: 1.0000
rmse: 0.3496
CS is a bit high at 1.7x weapon damage instead of 1.6x. Note that CS is based off of normalized weapon damage, while HotR is not. Once I have level 93 armor values, I'll use the exact values and see if I can do better.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
By the way, I wouldn't mind a data set with which to test Seal of Righteousness/Insight, Hammer of Wrath, Holy Prism, Execution Sentence, and Light's Hammer. Bonus points if you can test Sacred Shield / Eternal Flame somehow.
Re: A Call to Arms - MoP Mechanics Testing
Ok, I'll work on friday, or maybe tomorrow afternoon. (Got a raid in 20 mins =P)
Should I do the Naked + 7 for each Seal? Would 10 minutes of data per seal be enough or should I do 15 at least?
Should I do the Naked + 7 for each Seal? Would 10 minutes of data per seal be enough or should I do 15 at least?
