Petrus' Cataclysm Master Gear List

[Dunkan]

Just a suggestion, but how about merging the profession trinkets with the other trinkets?

Stuck out there like that makes it difficult to compare.

[Fayia]

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/l ... eil/simple

Seems Paragon discovered a tanking sword that is not on the list...the Fang of Twilight?

[Throb]

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/lightnings-blade/lazeil/simple

Seems Paragon discovered a tanking sword that is not on the list...the Fang of Twilight?

It drops off of Valonia and is an Agi/Crit/Mastery sword. So, it's a tanking sword in the same regard that Belt of the Ferocious Wolf is a tanking belt. It's good if you don't have anything better.

[Siral]

A question about Ironstar's Impenetrable Cover (not the heroic one).

For which tanking class is better than the reputation one? Not for sure for paladin (dodge/mastery >>>> dodge/parry)

[econ21]

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/lightnings-blade/lazeil/simple

Seems Paragon discovered a tanking sword that is not on the list...the Fang of Twilight?

It drops off of Valonia and is an Agi/Crit/Mastery sword. So, it's a tanking sword in the same regard that Belt of the Ferocious Wolf is a tanking belt. It's good if you don't have anything better.

Not quite - the agility makes it good for survival (whereas the belt is a strength item). It's more comparable to the Earthen ring reputation ring and the Don Flamingo's neck - something that is not intended for tanking, but may be better than comparable items that are intended for tanking. You are trading off some threat for some survivability. Compare it to the Mace of Acrid Death - that gives you 118 parry; but this sword gives you about 143 dodge (0.6*165 dodge from its agility and 44 dodge from reforging the crit).

I don't quite understand the prejudice against agility for tanks. It's like disdaining the WW2 88mm gun as an anti-tank weapon just because it was designed to shoot down planes, not tanks.

[Nikachelle]

If anything, this board was NOT prejudiced against agility at all for tanks. Most of us used agility/stam gems and agility enchants in Wrath. That being said, I don't know the current math, but it doesn't seem people are as gungho about agility in Cataclysm as they were before.

[Earantur]

Have you specifically avoided putting green gear on the list? There's a crafted belt(http://www.wowhead.com/item=55027) and quest reward belt(http://www.wowhead.com/item=63868) that both seem to me to be better than the starter zone blues on the list.

[econ21]

...the Fang of Twilight ... Compare it to the Mace of Acrid Death - that gives you 118 parry; but this sword gives you about 143 dodge (0.6*165 dodge from its agility and 44 dodge from reforging the crit).

Um, I realise I have forgotten the contribution of strength to parry from the Mace (0.25*165=41). That makes the mace better for survival. So the tanking weapon is better, but it is close (159 parry vs 143 dodge).

[lythac]

If anything, this board was NOT prejudiced against agility at all for tanks. Most of us used agility/stam gems and agility enchants in Wrath. That being said, I don't know the current math, but it doesn't seem people are as gungho about agility in Cataclysm as they were before.

It was the removal of agility providing armor, and str proving parry that killed it off mostly. In Cata there aren't any agility enchants/gems that are BiS and it is not a reforgable stat. So the only place to pick it up is on jewelry and it has to have mastery on to make it an option. And there are always str alternatives for the slot.

Agility is still teh sex.

Also we can't praise it too much as a lot of inexperienced paladins might start going for some weird items just because they have agility on them due to hearing agility provides more than twice the avoidance of str.

[aureon]

Why aren't the WotLK armor trinket present?
The petrified twilight scale off Halion is surely better than Bedrock talisman, and by a pretty wide margin.
Unidentifiable Organ seems VERY good, too.

[lythac]

Why aren't the WotLK armor trinket present?

Patch 4.0.6 - Lich King trinkets with bonus armor values have been adjusted using the new Cataclysm formula, reducing their armor values substantially.

Would be my guess.

[inthedrops]

Treck posted some missing waist and ring pieces from CoW and I think it's very important to have them in the gear list considering they are close to if not sometimes best in slot.

Here are a couple screenshots of some I've managed to grab. Treck included all the details you need to know though in his excellent post a page or two back:



(Note that the ring is ilvl 372)


Hah, I just realized you all get to know what I name my gearsets

[majorwoo]

Hah, I just realized you all get to know what I name my gearsets

I want to know the difference between "mastery" and "super mastery". I have a suspicion it is something I looked at doing myself, but decided against.

[inthedrops]

Hah, I just realized you all get to know what I name my gearsets

I want to know the difference between "mastery" and "super mastery". I have a suspicion it is something I looked at doing myself, but decided against.

It's more for fun than actual use in raids. It's the gear I have with the most mastery on it. Puts me a bit above 62% block and like 145k health. I don't think I've actually worn it in a raid though so it's more of a "how high can I go" thing.

[yappo]

It's more for fun than actual use in raids. It's the gear I have with the most mastery on it. Puts me a bit above 62% block and like 145k health. I don't think I've actually worn it in a raid though so it's more of a "how high can I go" thing.

You're sick and perverted

Extrapolating from my set it should see you at 93% CTC.

[inthedrops]

Hah, just checked:
145k health
10.29 dodge
13.34 parry
62.50% block
91.93 before raid buffs.

I still have a crappy helm with only 56 reforged mastery on it. But I equip Earthshape Pauldrons, The Lustrous Eye, and Red Rock Band as items I don't normally wear (I have better all around pieces). Obviously two mastery trinkets. I could probably get another 0.5% or more with some regemming but like I said, I've never tanked in this. Maybe I should try

I keep meaning to see what the heck CTC means but assume it just means hot close to unhittable one is.

Edit: Oh, Combat Table Coverage.

[Treck]

I think [Cloak of Biting Chill] should be added to the list, as it appears to be the best back ingame for us atm. For some reason theres no 372 "tanking" cloak available.

[yappo]

I think [Cloak of Biting Chill] should be added to the list, as it appears to be the best back ingame for us atm. For some reason theres no 372 "tanking" cloak available.

Hmm, we're going to see shammies, rogues and druids paying for hitmen to come after maintankadin

And yes, I'm well aware that the agi/mastery slots tend to be fantastic for us. Just hard to convince the agi-dps that we're rolling on a tanking-upgrade. Looks a bit similar to holydins rolling on cloth the last X-pac.

[Treck]

Just hard to convince the agi-dps that we're rolling on a tanking-upgrade. Looks a bit similar to holydins rolling on cloth the last X-pac.

Atleast everywhere i went, it was generally acceptable for paladins (of both holy and ret) to sport mail/leather/cloth just cuz the stats were better and the armor didnt make any real difference anyway.
If its BiS, its BiS, be it for a tank or a dps.
Who its the biggest upgrade for, is another story, but its also more of a guild based decision at that point

[yappo]

Who its the biggest upgrade for, is another story, but its also more of a guild based decision at that point

Ah, but I'm a puggie

[Digren]

Treck posted some missing waist and ring pieces from CoW and I think it's very important to have them in the gear list considering they are close to if not sometimes best in slot.

Here are a couple screenshots of some I've managed to grab. Treck included all the details you need to know though in his excellent post a page or two back:

These are pretty good. Details for all three tanking options:

...of the Bedrock
+380 Stamina, +232 Strength, +160 Mastery Rating, +160 Parry Rating
...of the Bouldercrag
+380 Stamina, +232 Strength, +160 Dodge Rating, +160 Parry Rating
...of the Rockslab
+380 Stamina, +232 Strength, +160 Mastery Rating, +160 Dodge Rating

I've flagged Rockstab and Bedrock as best in slot, with Bouldercrag behind. All three are better than the Hardened Elementium Girdle and the Jumbotron Power Belt, at least in my maths.

[Treck]

I wouldnt say

...of the Bouldercrag
+380 Stamina, +232 Strength, +160 Dodge Rating, +160 Parry Rating

Is better than Jumbotron Power Belt
But both Bedrock and Rockslab are great alternatives to Jumbotron as comparing normal vs normal and hc vs hc, the throne loot wins over Omnotrons.

[Digren]

I wouldnt say

...of the Bouldercrag
+380 Stamina, +232 Strength, +160 Dodge Rating, +160 Parry Rating

Is better than Jumbotron Power Belt
But both Bedrock and Rockslab are great alternatives to Jumbotron as comparing normal vs normal and hc vs hc, the throne loot wins over Omnotrons.

Both have identical stamina and armor. Once properly enhanced, and assuming that parry is reforged to mastery on the Bouldercrag, the differences are:

Code: Select all

Jumbotron           Bouldercrag
+95 mastery rating
                    +21 dodge rating
                    +111 parry rating

We need to assume existing values for post-DR dodge and parry, which I'll set to 13.5% dodge and 14.5% parry (about the numbers that Theck's raid gear set has).

What I want to do is calculate the amount of mastery rating necessary to equal the damage reduction of the Bouldercrag's avoidance rating. From Theck's maths:

Code: Select all

dD/Do = -dAr*Fa/(Ar+K)*[1-Av-0.4*B] - Fa*[dAv+0.4*dB]           (4)

Fortunately dAr is 0 in this comparison. I will break dAv down into dAvd and dAvp.

Code: Select all

dD/Do = - Fa*[dAvd + dAvp + 0.4*dB]

Because we're trying to find an equivalence, we want the amount of dB such that

Code: Select all

dAvd + dAvp = 0.4 * dB

From Theck

Code: Select all

dA' = (dA/k)*(1-A'/C)^2   (10)

Where dA' is the post-DR avoidance provided by pre-DR dA, A' is character sheet post-DR avoidance (i.e. (char_sheet_dodge_% - 3.9705) or (char_sheet_parry_% - 5)).

dA must be derived from rating, which is "0.01*dRv/Ca, the added avoidance rating divided by the avoidance rating conversion factor (Ca=176.7189) times 0.01 to put it in decimal notation."
Thus

Code: Select all

dAd = 0.01 * 21 / 176.7189 = 0.00119        (A)
dAp = 0.01 * 111 / 176.7189 = 0.00628       (B)
Ad' = 0.135 - 0.039705 = 0.095295           (C)
Ap' = 0.145 - 0.05 = 0.095                  (D)
k = 0.9560
C = 0.65631440
dAvd = 0.000908                             (E)
dAvp = 0.004805                             (F)

Thus

Code: Select all

dAvd + dAvp = 0.005714 = 0.4 * dB
dB = 0.01428                                (G)

dB is easy to convert to dRm, because dB = 0.0225/Cm*dRm where Cm=179.28 @ level 85 per Theck. Thus

Code: Select all

dB * Cm / 0.0225 = dRm
dRm = 113.8

In other words, given my initial assumptions, it would take 114 mastery rating to equal the damage-reduction of 21 dodge rating plus 111 parry rating. This seems to make sense; in Theck's math in his derivation spreadsheet, he assumed smaller percentages of post-DR avoidance, and yielded a result where 122 mastery rating was equal to 132 avoidance rating. Here, I'm assuming a raider with greater DR, and thus slightly less mastery rating is necessary to match the avoidance rating.

So what does that mean? Well, the Jumbotron only provides 95 mastery rating, less than the 114 mastery rating necessary to match the Bouldercrag. Thus, Thunder Wall Belt of the Bouldercrag (non-heroic) is better than the Jumbotron Power Belt (non-heroic) for damage reduction.

[Digren]

I edited the above to correct a previous mis-statement.

[Treck]

This seems to make sense; in Theck's math in his derivation spreadsheet, he assumed smaller percentages of post-DR avoidance, and yielded a result where 122 mastery rating was equal to 132 avoidance rating.

So what does that mean? Well, the Jumbotron only provides 95 mastery rating, less than the 114 mastery rating necessary to match the Bouldercrag.

Im not doubting your math, im just very suprised at the mastery vs avoidance correlations.
I thought 122mastery would be a lot better than just equal to 132 avoidance rating.
Altho i have noticed something of this effect while using Chardev, since i dont do the math, i let that do it for me (to see the % gain from different gearparts, and i do hope its correct)

Atleast i got 372 of the rockslab on both ring/belt, so im not looking for any upgrades ^^