Sarth Heroic Sub 21 Achievement

[Jaedyn]

Just a question out there for you guys, anyone else done this? My guild completed it tonight, and for how ridiculously easy it seemed I'm surprised that WoWJutsu had literally 0.0% guilds completed (Obviously I don't believe we are the ONLY guild to do it, but I figured there would be more).

[knaughty]

I'd guess most are working on adding drakes.

[amh]

We almost got it last week, but two people logged on just as we were summoning the raid. Getting people badges / free loot > achievement.

[Valsh]

Got this the first week when going for realm first, with 15 people =/

[Ewige]

Yeah, we definitely did this pretty early (maybe second week) on with 18 (or 19) people. You can do it with even less, as a few dps died pretty early on; just takes longer.

[fafhrd]

I'd guess most are working on adding drakes.

[enbee]

Considering he's mindnumbingly easy with 25 with no drakes up, he can probably be done with as few as 10...

[Andox]

I also find it strange since he is so easy. We got this as the 4'th guild on Neptulon-EU, which I find very strange since we didn't go so fast on progress.

[Lousiana]

Getting people badges / free loot > achievement.

This.

[majiben]

QQ

We just did this with 21 people instead of 20 because we misunderstood the achievement. The good news is I pulled a whopping 2.8k dps as ret with one nax drop (Demise but the titansteel destroyer is it's equal).

[Jaedyn]

I guess I wasn't clear in my original post. Due to the ridiculously easy nature of this boss, I'm surprised some small/casual guilds that only do 10's haven't done it. It doesn't require any sort of ridiculous gearing to do, so I assumed guilds with 15-17 people would be all over it, since they could easily accomplish it.

We just happened to have a ton of people taking finals so we kinda said screw it and just downed him with what we had on at the time for shits and giggles.

[phaqueue]

I guess I wasn't clear in my original post. Due to the ridiculously easy nature of this boss, I'm surprised some small/casual guilds that only do 10's haven't done it. It doesn't require any sort of ridiculous gearing to do, so I assumed guilds with 15-17 people would be all over it, since they could easily accomplish it.

We just happened to have a ton of people taking finals so we kinda said screw it and just downed him with what we had on at the time for shits and giggles.

my take on this is people who are in those guilds may be "scared" so to speak of 25 man content... remember - the original idea was that 25-man content was harder than 10 man.. and required more gear... we know this isn't necessarily the case... but perhaps people in those kind of guilds haven't been to the fight on 25 man - and don't realize how much of a pushover he really is... (pretty sure even the 25 man is puggable like it's nothing)

[PsiVen]

It should be noted that wowjutsu is nowhere near as reliable as it once was. They apparently did a single pass after most everyone who was going to kill Malygos in the first couple weeks did so, didn't care what order the kills happened in, and have been doing a poor job detecting achievements since.

[Mephesto97]

My guild did this our first week of raiding. We had only 18-20 people @80 and decided to try out the boss. We killed him and the spider wind in Naxx with only 18 people.

[knaughty]

Just ran everything but Malygos 20-man Sunday/Monday night, as we only had 15-20 people online.

Only had 5 healers... turns out you can clear everything with 5.

We did Sarth+1 20-man, because +0 is a joke.

Got too late to do Malygos, can't see he would have been difficult.

Thaddius is probably the only thing that's actually a challenge 20-man. We had less than 3 seconds till enrage when he died, and our execution was pretty good.

=edit=

4-horseman is difficult as well to do with 20. Enough that the achievement doesn't actually require that you do them undermanned. We had to, as we were doing "under-manned" due to lack of manpower. Actually had PuGs for most of Naxx (not Thaddius, military wing or Sapph/KT)