So... our 11pt talent will be...

[amadiss]

I'm worried right know because we were just discussing our survivability a week ago. We were wondering weteher our 11pt talent would compensate our deficiencies and make us as good as warriors.

But now we may get our expected 11pt talent and its going to be something that will put our threat almost where it was before the judgment nerf.

Then well be acknowledged to be "on par up to a negligible percent" .

I hope i'm wrong.

[Dianora]

[Pointless QQ is pointless. -Lore]

[Macha]

It probably won't be threat: Ret could grab that easily.

Don't worry about the 11 pointer, it'll take months before it is even considered, as GC admitted.

[Vika]

I'd like to see an actual tanking seal. Maybe something that does holy damage and puts a charge on the boss each time we dodge/block/parry judging does X damage per charge. Something like that. Obviously something would have to be done to prevent it from scaling through the roof as we gear, but it seems like a reasonable fix for the recent seal nerf and basing it on avoidance + block would deal with some of the issues we've seen with rets and seals.

[Karock]

Mmmm I actually like that idea.

A seal that scales off of Block Value, have it's coefficient buffed by adding on to lower tier talents. Would give prot paladin a more viable soloing option even at low levels as well as a better raiding seal.

[Kysen]

They will move BoK back to 11 pt and tier 1 will be.

Divine Un-nerf

Increases the threat on all seals by 4% (5 ranks)

Will have the same retarded side arrow too.

[Io.Draco]

That would be the most bad idea , we need more DPS , NOT for our abilities to simply do more threat

[Andryana]

Our 11-point talent is a myth.

[amadiss]

If we would get only threat and toughness with no damage we would be exactly where prot warriors used to be. Mhhh...

[Kysen]

That would be the most bad idea , we need more DPS , NOT for our abilities to simply do more threat

There's no way they'll be giving you more dps that low in the tree or rets will take it and we all know how that will end up.

[Worldie]

That would be the most bad idea , we need more DPS , NOT for our abilities to simply do more threat

There's no way they'll be giving you more dps that low in the tree or rets will take it and we all know how that will end up.

They can just add anything higher. However, a ability usable only with a 1h and/or shield sounds fine as 11 pointer.

Hell, ShoR as 11 pointer and a new ability at 75 would be great.

[Karock]

At this point I want a new prot specific seal that scales in a way that ret paladin won't want it. >.> our old seals suck.

[Elsie]

That would be the most bad idea , we need more DPS , NOT for our abilities to simply do more threat

There's no way they'll be giving you more dps that low in the tree or rets will take it and we all know how that will end up.

They can just add anything higher. However, a ability usable only with a 1h and/or shield sounds fine as 11 pointer.

Hell, ShoR as 11 pointer and a new ability at 75 would be great.

I'm voting for Sacred Shield, and a useful ability at 80 then.

[Bobness]

I'm voting for Sacred Shield, and a useful ability at 80 then.

Fine for soloing... but geeze less damage/ less mana/ less threat

no thanks.

[Worldie]

I'm voting for Sacred Shield, and a useful ability at 80 then.

but geeze less damage/ less mana/ less threat
.

?
Sanctuary takes perfectly care of all our mana, and 1kish absorbed damage where things hit for 7k+ aint going to affect your mana regeneration.