What enchant for prot now then??

[Mavrix]

well the only duel purpose stats i can see as a weapon enchant are agility and strength, agility will up crit chance on hammer and shield punch and maybe judgments.

What does pvp have to do with it? ;P

[Lightbeard]

ima probaly be sticking to spell damage

[Blutreich]

*sorry about spelling, double purpose stats as in mitigation and threat*

[Zonzede]

ima probaly be sticking to spell damage

..

When all of our abilities now scale with AP as well as SP, including Consecration, Seals, and Judgments, you may have to rethink this based on math when it's solidified

[Snake-Aes]

ima probaly be sticking to spell damage

..

When all of our abilities now scale with AP as well as SP, including Consecration, Seals, and Judgments, you may have to rethink this based on math when it's solidified

Based on what enchants will be available*
Unless htere's a "X str", "2X ap" or similars, X spell damage will be the enchant of choice

[Worldie]

I'm actually going for the new version of Mongoose/Agility enchants.

I'm a avoidance whore, i know. Screw aggro, noone can overaggro me anyway.

[Lemondish]

ima probaly be sticking to spell damage

..

When all of our abilities now scale with AP as well as SP, including Consecration, Seals, and Judgments, you may have to rethink this based on math when it's solidified

Based on what enchants will be available*
Unless htere's a "X str", "2X ap" or similars, X spell damage will be the enchant of choice

Why not Potency? We're talking about going INTO WotLK, not at the end of it. There will no doubt be a proper enchant at that point. Potency provides +20 Strength to a 1 hander, is relatively easy to acquire, and provides 40 AP for use on scaling our abilties and 10 Block Value.

Spell damage simply benefits a few of our abilities (some of which now scale better with AP).

[Grothnir]

At least one of my weapons will have Scourgebane for maximum anti-undead threat. All else remains to be seen.

[Jonlo]

I'm actually going for the new version of Mongoose/Agility enchants.

I'm a avoidance whore, i know. Screw aggro, noone can overaggro me anyway.

Why is your sig not ponytail updated yet?

[thejuice]

i still think it would be BA if there was an enchant with a proc for an extra weapon swing.

[Norrath]

ima probaly be sticking to spell damage

..

When all of our abilities now scale with AP as well as SP, including Consecration, Seals, and Judgments, you may have to rethink this based on math when it's solidified

Based on what enchants will be available*
Unless htere's a "X str", "2X ap" or similars, X spell damage will be the enchant of choice

Why not Potency? We're talking about going INTO WotLK, not at the end of it. There will no doubt be a proper enchant at that point. Potency provides +20 Strength to a 1 hander, is relatively easy to acquire, and provides 40 AP for use on scaling our abilties and 10 Block Value.

Spell damage simply benefits a few of our abilities (some of which now scale better with AP).

Potency only represents half the itemization points Major Spellpower does. Our abilities scale both with AP and SP, but that scaling keeps in mind that AP costs half the itemization points that SP does.

Yes, Major Spellpower won't affect some of our abilities, but it will still be more bang for the buck.

[Akushi]

raw SP+ vs raw STR+ is something that is very different as every skill of ours now changes off of AP and SP, i know not all the maths are accurate on wowhead, but there is such an insignificant difference between them that the amount of things raw STR+ affects is by far a better choice of enchant for threat.

STR benefits
Melee swings
SotR
HotR
Consecrate/Holy Shield/Exorcism
Judgements+Seals

SP Benefits
Consecrate/Holy Shield/Exorcism
Judgements+Seals

But all in all i think i'm going to go with Worldi and get me some Mongoose action.

[Snake-Aes]

raw SP+ vs raw STR+ is something that is very different as every skill of ours now changes off of AP and SP, i know not all the maths are accurate on wowhead, but there is such an insignificant difference between them that the amount of things raw STR+ affects is by far a better choice of enchant for threat.

STR benefits
Melee swings
SotR
HotR
Consecrate/Holy Shield/Exorcism
Judgements+Seals

SP Benefits
Consecrate/Holy Shield/Exorcism
Judgements+Seals

But all in all i think i'm going to go with Worldi and get me some Mongoose action.

Holy shield is only SP.

Easier way to looking at what scales:

AP:
Everything but heals and holy shield
SP:
Everything before HotR

[Norrath]

ShoR doesn't scale with SP either, I believe. It doesn't even scale with AP, just BV.

[ulushnar]

ShoR doesn't scale with SP either, I believe. It doesn't even scale with AP, just BV.

So it does scale with Strength, ifyouknowwhatimean?