Shield Help

[Liadrin]

Today I won a Shield of Impenetrable Darkness from Nightbane because the warrior already had the Aldori Legacy and I thought it looked cool.

http://www.wowhead.com/?item=28606

I am currently using she Sha'Tar shield http://www.wowhead.com/?item=29176 socketed with two Solid Stars, and would give me about 10 more stam but less armor, defense, and shield block value.

Which one should I use? 10 stam is great, I look for stam everywhere I go, but is the Nightbane shield better overall?

Thanks.

[Mavrix]

Really I do think after the buff that the nightbane shield is superior to the sha'tar. I'm not entirely convinced that it's not superior in some ways to the aldori as well.

[Liadrin]

Really I do think after the buff that the nightbane shield is superior to the sha'tar. I'm not entirely convinced that it's not superior in some ways to the aldori as well.

Care to elaborate?

[Thels]

Shield of Impenetrable Darkness:
4872 Armor, 155 Block, 33 Sta, 22 DefR (1.1% avoidance)

Crest of the Sha'tar:
4465 Armor, 132 Block, 43 Sta, 13 DefR, 3 DodgeR (0.8% avoidance)

+407 Armor, +23 Block, -10 Sta, +0.3% avoidance)

Worth the 10 stamina? I'd say so.



Aldori Legacy Defender:
5279 Armor, 137 Block, 51 Sta, 21 DefR (1.05% avoidance), 15 HitR

-407 Armor, +18 Block, -18 Sta, +0.05% Avoidance, -15 HitR.

I'd never take the SoID over the ALD.