[10] What is your damage looking like?

[Er]

I didn't see any topics like this, so.. here goes.

I decided last night to actually parse the place and I was shocked to see my damage (I'm Er, obviously.) I was tanking the place with Haerokos.

What gives with the difference in damage? Is he that much worse? Either way, what kind of numbers do you push out?

http://wowwebstats.com/54snx3tglt53w

[Ashmadai]

Just looks to me like the other guy didn't consecrate as much as you and didn't get all the Holy shield damage you did. He probably knew you were handling all the trash and just stood there half assedly. I was around 1700 to 1800 for the whole run of Naxx, same for the Warrior tank.

[Er]

It's possible. Either way, I did notice his consecrate damage in the WWS incredibly low, but I'm still perplexed as to why. The ret paladins' consecrate damage came in just fine.


Not to mention that I still pushed huge numbers tanking. Working as intended or did I break the system >.>

[Ashmadai]

I'm fairly certain your other tank just didn't do a lot of consecrating because he knew you were holding agro. Me and my Warrior buddy co MT and on trash we both just grab a ton of stuff and see who can do the most damage while it gets AoEed down. =) You certainly didn't break anything. Your amount of damage done and DPS is about in line with what me and the Warrior tank do in there.

If anything, your DPS needs to pick it up. We have a hunter that sustains about 3200 in our Naxx 10 group, doing almost 5k on bosses. Then we have a DK, Ret, and Shadow Priest that all maintain about 2500 for the whole run. None of these people are fully Naxx 10 geared either. We only started Naxx this past weekend, and cleared everything but Kel'thuzad once so far.

[search66]

We start Naxx on Sunday... but our guild heroic groups DPS range from about 1800-2800 (5 mans). My dps is around 1500-1800.

[Er]

I'm fairly certain your other tank just didn't do a lot of consecrating because he knew you were holding agro.

I'm referring more to this.

http://wowwebstats.com/54snx3tglt53w?ab=48819

Look at the damage his consecrate was apparently doing.

[Ashmadai]

That has to be some sort of bug. It says his Consecrate ticked almost 2900 times but only did 29000 total damage? I don't think so...Not unless he was rocking a rank 1 consecrate, and even that shouldn't be that low.

[gwayne]

That has to be some sort of bug. It says his Consecrate ticked almost 2900 times but only did 29000 total damage? I don't think so...Not unless he was rocking a rank 1 consecrate, and even that shouldn't be that low.

Actually Rank 1 consecrate probably only ticks for about 10 at level 80. I haven't tested this or anything but I remember reading that the scaling component of down ranked spells falls to almost nothing when you are a much higher level. Rank one does 9 + scaling factor per tick so this could explain it quite nicely

[luebeck]

Well with an offtank pally he could very easily just have run out of mana not taking any damage and not getting as much heals to replenish it.

We ran naxx with 2 pally tanks so just by competing with another pally for threat i noticed once the other has em you may as well stop dropping consecration and save mana should another patrol group creep up on your group, which happened to us a lot on our first time through; for an offtank pally with no mana is pretty much useless.