I just tanked Utgarde Keep :)

[AutomaticZen]

Wait. We can Judge multiple mobs now? I totally missed that.

you can do that now actually... just not at the same time if thats what you're thinking

Yeah. That's pretty much what it sounded like he was saying. To test if it procced multiples, you'd need another pally. It sounded like he was going to do it by himself, so I was wondering if something changed. Otherwise, Divine Storm would be a very, very nice ability for Ret.

[Arees]

Wait. We can Judge multiple mobs now? I totally missed that.

you can do that now actually... just not at the same time if thats what you're thinking

Yeah. That's pretty much what it sounded like he was saying. To test if it procced multiples, you'd need another pally. It sounded like he was going to do it by himself, so I was wondering if something changed. Otherwise, Divine Storm would be a very, very nice ability for Ret.

no... what im saying you can do right now is judge wisdom on mob 1, tab to mob 2 and judge wisdom when the cd is up and they will both have wisdom... if you keep tabbing between them you can refresh the judgment on both... so you could throws wisdom on two mobs this way to test it

[d503]

no... what im saying you can do right now is judge wisdom on mob 1, tab to mob 2 and judge wisdom when the cd is up and they will both have wisdom... if you keep tabbing between them you can refresh the judgment on both... so you could throws wisdom on two mobs this way to test it

This.

Sorry if it wasn't clear. Posting on Maintankadin from your Centro is a bit laborious I try to type as little as possible!

[Andox]

Judgement of Wisdom hits %t for 870 Holy.
Judgement of Righteousness hits %t for 750 Holy.

I don´t understand this.

Is it when you Judge wisdom the seal deals almost DOUBLE damage? Or did I get it wrong?

Btw, is the standard judgement still there?

[Vanifae]

Judgement of Wisdom hits %t for 870 Holy.
Judgement of Righteousness hits %t for 750 Holy.

I don´t understand this.

Is it when you Judge wisdom the seal deals almost DOUBLE damage? Or did I get it wrong?

Btw, is the standard judgement still there?

Judgment is gone now.

[d503]

Judgement of Wisdom hits %t for 870 Holy.
Judgement of Righteousness hits %t for 750 Holy.

I don´t understand this.

Is it when you Judge wisdom the seal deals almost DOUBLE damage? Or did I get it wrong?

Btw, is the standard judgement still there?

I'll try and get a screenie of this later...

[Andox]

The thign that I don´t get is if JoW do damage, or if JoR dmg gets doubled. btw, how is JoV/Corr in this case?

[Kelaan]

I probably was overgeared from an avoidance standpoint to really test the viability of mana regen in this instance. There's just not enough damage coming in...it would be like if I jumped in normal SL or Arc right now in my current tanking gear.

How viable would it be to pull multiple groups, then? Have the warrior pull one with a bow, taunt off of him, and let everything run into a consecrate? "Pull Moar or sit" seems to be the mantra when outgearing stuff, even if it's not something I yet can do.

[d503]

I probably was overgeared from an avoidance standpoint to really test the viability of mana regen in this instance. There's just not enough damage coming in...it would be like if I jumped in normal SL or Arc right now in my current tanking gear.

How viable would it be to pull multiple groups, then? Have the warrior pull one with a bow, taunt off of him, and let everything run into a consecrate? "Pull Moar or sit" seems to be the mantra when outgearing stuff, even if it's not something I yet can do.

Did that a couple of times...it wasn't bad, but even when pulling 8-10 mobs, I'd still just end up OOM as they got DPS'd down. Keep in mind that we were 4-manning as well, with all melee DPS and a Holy Pally, so there was little AOE to be had (both from the healing side and the dmg side).

Looking back, I could probably pull half of the wings at this point, but I didn't want to push it in our first attempt there. The trash is pretty boring...either melee dudes or a couple of casters...nothing exciting or worth noting.

[d503]

Judgement of Wisdom hits %t for 870 Holy.
Judgement of Righteousness hits %t for 750 Holy.

I don´t understand this.

Is it when you Judge wisdom the seal deals almost DOUBLE damage? Or did I get it wrong?

Not double damage, but that the combat log would see two Judgements hitting, and they would both do independent damage in the combat log (as noted above).

The damage, however, was consolidated into one scrolling combat text number, which is generally not true for blizzard's implementation of SCT.

[d503]

Not double damage, but that the combat log would see two Judgements hitting, and they would both do independent damage in the combat log (as noted above).

The damage, however, was consolidated into one scrolling combat text number, which is generally not true for blizzard's implementation of SCT.

Going back through combat logs, I was apparently drugged from a contact high that traveled on the winds from Berkeley or something b/c I don't see this 2x judgement stuff...

I think what I was seeing, was that Judgement was hitting for XXX and then Judgement of Whatever was returning XXX to me, so I was skimming a bit too much and not reading >.>

False alarm! Move along people >.>

[Arjuna]

I'm never gonna get an answer to my question...
I even opened up a topic of my own just for it but nobody would test it
Is it just me that is being stupid and it is obvious to everybody else?

What I would like to know is:

Judge mob 1 with whatever --> tab --> judge mob 2 with whatever --> HotR

Is the judgement on mob 1 refreshed with HotR and does HotR proc judgements? does HotR proc judgements on both targets if both mob 1 and 2 has judgements?


forgive my stupidity and/ur unability to scan the forum for a post that answers my question in case I missed it...

[Worldie]

hotr procs judgement

hotr doesn't refresh judgements on other mobs

[Arjuna]

finally!

thank you worldie!!!

[Worldie]

And they could have added a tank ring to the quest in Utgarde Keep