Illidan tanked by paladin on proudmoore

[sindorei]

Lunacy is the first guild killed illidan on proudmoore server and the website also said is tanked by a prot paladin.
here is the link:
http://www.lunacy-guild.net/lunacy/

the paladin:

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-shee ... &n=Teckbot

i am not sure if teckbot is the person who tanked him.
we just need someone to confirm this :p

[Eliane]

His post on EJ: http://elitistjerks.com/521957-post71.html

[Worldie]

If this Paladin tanked him, he has some lack of knowledge.

- Holy Shield sucks for MT purposes as it is now - it is impossible to remain uncrushable reliably with it on boss fights because of the .5-1sec lag-time between it falling off and the cooldown allowing you to put it back on... as opposed to Shield block that has 1sec longer duration than the cooldown.

As far as i know, Illidan cannot crush.

And i've never heard of buff caps, or well, how damn many resto druids they use? If they use 2-3 resto druids, i'm not surprised his healers had hard times keeping him topped up, since they quite fail at main tank healing for spikedamages...

On other hand, he makes a right comment about Tankadins hit points being too low, but luckily this issue is solved in 2.3, and in his current gear he would have 16k+ HP unbuffed...

[Atreidies]

If this Paladin tanked him, he has some lack of knowledge.

As far as i know, Illidan cannot crush.

He was talking in general terms and he's absolutely right, although I believe most will agree that it's not on the top of people's list of things that need to be dealt with.

And i've never heard of buff caps, or well, how damn many resto druids they use? If they use 2-3 resto druids, i'm not surprised his healers had hard times keeping him topped up, since they quite fail at main tank healing for spikedamages...

There has always been a buff/debuff cap in the game, and there are 'invisible' buffs such as Defensive/Battle/Berserker Stance, etc. that all factor into this and can push off buffs as new ones are applied.

[Worldie]

If this Paladin tanked him, he has some lack of knowledge.

As far as i know, Illidan cannot crush.

He was talking in general terms and he's absolutely right, although I believe most will agree that it's not on the top of people's list of things that need to be dealt with.

In this case he's obviously right, and also you are right since this is rarely a issue.

[sindorei]

If this Paladin tanked him, he has some lack of knowledge.

As far as i know, Illidan cannot crush.

He was talking in general terms and he's absolutely right, although I believe most will agree that it's not on the top of people's list of things that need to be dealt with.

And i've never heard of buff caps, or well, how damn many resto druids they use? If they use 2-3 resto druids, i'm not surprised his healers had hard times keeping him topped up, since they quite fail at main tank healing for spikedamages...

There has always been a buff/debuff cap in the game, and there are 'invisible' buffs such as Defensive/Battle/Berserker Stance, etc. that all factor into this and can push off buffs as new ones are applied.

yeah i hate the GCD on holy shield,especially on PTR2.3

[Warrender]

As far as i know, Illidan cannot crush.

No, but he does have the Shear mechanic which Holy Shield will help guard against.

[Lore]

Although it's certainly a great accomplishment, you don't need to post it twice. Please keep it to the first thread: http://www.failsafedesign.com/maintanka ... php?t=3319